Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Why I'm not seeing Thor


I know I promised a review, and I am sorry, but I can't go see this movie. I just don't want to.

I was all prepared to go. I grabbed my wallet and keys and headed out the door, and it didn't strike me until I was in the elevator how much I don't care about this movie. Why did I even think I did?

I was 14 when
X-Men came out and though I never read the comics, I was a fan of the cartoon show and there was no way I was going to miss the movie. And while I can look back now and find huge flaws, it worked for teenage me. Two years later, Spider-Man came out and, again, thanks to the cartoon, I was excited for the movie. From there, comic book adaptations became a summer institution and I saw all of them. Some were good (Spider-Man 2) and some were awful (Spider-Man 3) but I was always there, usually on opening night. Then Iron Man 2 came out.

The first Iron Man was a genuinely good movie. It's bogged down by stupid action (a requirement in these types of movies) but it features a great central performance from Robert Downey, Jr. in service of a character who receives real development. A big problem in this genre is that the characters don't change - when you're already a hero, where is there to go? They're self-righteous at the beginning and self-righteous at the end. By making Tony Stark an asshole arms dealer, the filmmakers left their hero room to grow. He's still an asshole at the end but he's on the right side. Unfortunately, this isn't a formula that can really be repeated and, even more unfortunately, this didn't stop them from making Iron Man 2.

There's a lot of problems with that movie, from Stark's stagnation to its sloppy libertarian message, but the biggest problem is that the man behind the curtain didn't even bother putting the curtain up in the first place. In the first one, Stark is contacted by S.H.I.E.L.D., a shadowy government agency, but they didn't receive much attention. In the sequel, they dominate the story, which doesn't really have anything to do with them. While Stark is fighting to protect the free market (or something), S.H.I.E.L.D. is trying to recruit him, sending undercover agents to infiltrate his entourage. By the time the credits rolled, it became painful obvious that Iron Man 2 was less a movie than a two hour commercial for the upcoming Avengers movie.

It's embarrassing, but I'll confess that I trusted Marvel. They're a huge corporation1 but they seemed to have such good intentions. They brought in good directors, who brought in good actors, to tell honest (if simplistic) stories. But now, it'd be naive to think that was ever the truth. They pander to the audience, giving us whatever (they think) we want to ensure that we buy a ticket. Which we do. Despite being terrible, Iron Man 2 made $600 million worldwide. Spider-Man 3 is one of the worst movies of all-time and it made close to $900 million.

Which is not to say that Thor is a bad movie. I haven't seen it, so how could I say? But more importantly, who cares?2 Did I leave the house today because I thought Thor it was going to be good? No. Did I leave the house because I'm a big Thor fan? Not at all. I don't really know anything about the character or the comic. All I know is that the movie was released during the summer, just like all those other movies that the industry trained me to assume I have to go see.

And this isn't to say you shouldn't go see Thor. If you're a fan, go. I'll probably see X-Men: First Class, even though it's the fifth movie in a mass-produced series3. I know this, but I also know that Michael Fassbender and Jennifer Lawrence are great actors, and that they happen to be playing mutants. All I'm asking is that you really want to go see a movie, and have a reason why, before you give them their money (especially if you see it in 3D)4. Make them earn it.

1That was recently purchased by Disney for $4 billion.
2Answer: Not Marvel.
3Almost literally. If FOX doesn't keep churning out X-Men films, they'll lose the rights.
4Don't see it in 3D. It's a scam.

Saturday, May 7, 2011

"03:34 - Terremoto en Chile"

(2011, d. Juan Pablo Ternicier, w. Mateo Iribarren)

While President Piñera might disagree, the most significant moment of what turned out to be a momentous year for Chile was the earthquake (The Earthquake) that struck the country on the morning of February 27. Along with his inauguration (which made him the first democratically elected president from the right in fifty years, not to mention since the dictatorship), Piñera would surely prefer that Chile in 2010 be remembered for Los 33, the thirty-three miners who survived being trapped underground two months, and the patriotism that their plight generated. But while everyone might remember where they were when they heard the miners had been found (lost in the hills of Valparaíso, for instance), everyone has a story about where they were when the earthquake hit. Even those who were still in San Diego at the time.

With that in mind, it makes sense that 03:34, the first fictional production about the earthquake to be released in Chile, is a hyperlink film. For anyone who doesn't know, a hyperlink film is one that interweaves the stories of multiple characters to tell one greater story1. Think of the films of Stephen Gaghan (Traffic, Syriana) or Alejandro González Iñárritu (Amores Perros, Babel). Don't think of Crash, though.

With the earthquake tying things together, this movie sets out to tell four stories: a group of friends, one a drug dealer, on vacation at the beach; a woman, whose estranged husband has also taken their children to the beach; an elderly couple who throw a birthday party for their orphaned granddaugther; and two prisoners, one with a heart of gold who breaks out to find his daughter2 and one who's a total psychopath.

First and foremost, the scenes set during the quake, as well as the following tsunami, are phenomenal and lend the movie brief moments of power. The sheer strength of the event is captured perfectly. Through the destruction of an apartment complex, which we witness from the inside, we see the physical ferocity in action. The same can be said for a later scene, in which a beachside house is destroyed during the tsunami. Both are tastefully and respectably done, and they really show the human toll that was inflicted. Unfortunately, they are the only two scenes in the movie that are either tasteful or respectable.

The biggest problem that this movie has is that the earthquake at the center of it actually happened. If this movie had been based on a fictional catastrophe, it might have passed as a higher brow version of the type of destruction porn Roland Emmerich has made a career out of directing. Too much time is wasted on stupid bull shit, to put it one way. It seems that the filmmakers didn't think that the inherent of drama of the earthquake was enough for them, so they had to cram in ridiculous motivations for their characters. Instead of simply trying to survive the earthquake and tsunami, gun-wielding rapists are set on the characters as well. It's possible, though, that the stakes were raised as they were because the characters themselves are flat and one-note at best. Of the people on screen that we're supposed to care about, only a few get any sort of development, and even that doesn't usually go much further than "mother" or "father" or "whiney loser that the audience is supposed to relate to."

It's easy to get the impression, watching this movie (not to mention looking back on it critically), that the filmmakers didn't really have an interest in telling the story of the 8.8 richter scale earthquake that tore Chile apart on February 27. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that this was a screenplay that had been lying around before then. But while movies have been made utilizing real world destruction for fictional purposes3, that was never an option here. However, instead of taking a hint and respecting the impact that his earthquake had on a country full of human beings, half-hearted reverence was tacked onto what can really be best described as an exploitation film.

With such hot topic subjects, there's usually something to be said about being first out of the gate and for better or worse, 03:34 did that. It's about all it accomplished, though. With so many stories out there, I hope other filmmakers are not dissuaded from telling them because this schlock beat them to the theaters.


1 At least, that's how I'm using it here.
2 Hmm, I wonder who that could be.
3 Off the top of my head, there's last year's Monsters, which used the destruction left behind by Hurricane Ike as a stand-in for the destruction left behind by an alien attack.

Welcome / Bienvenidos

Welcome to my blog. After five or six years of contemplation, I've finally broken down and signed up. Assuming that I stick with it (which isn't a very strong bet), you can expect to read a variety of complaints and observations, and more complaints, on everything from politics to comic book movies that I'll probably go see even though I don't really want to.

The idea is that keeping a blog will build up my discipline but as that is not going to happen, expect semi-erratic updates.

See you soon!,
Stephen